- Open Access
Divergent evolution and purifying selection of the flaA gene sequences in Aeromonas
© Farfán et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2009
Received: 15 July 2009
Accepted: 21 July 2009
Published: 21 July 2009
The bacterial flagellum is the most important organelle of motility in bacteria and plays a key role in many bacterial lifestyles, including virulence. The flagellum also provides a paradigm of how hierarchical gene regulation, intricate protein-protein interactions and controlled protein secretion can result in the assembly of a complex multi-protein structure tightly orchestrated in time and space. As if to stress its importance, plants and animals produce receptors specifically dedicated to the recognition of flagella. Aside from motility, the flagellum also moonlights as an adhesion and has been adapted by humans as a tool for peptide display. Flagellar sequence variation constitutes a marker with widespread potential uses for studies of population genetics and phylogeny of bacterial species.
We sequenced the complete flagellin gene (flaA) in 18 different species and subspecies of Aeromonas. Sequences ranged in size from 870 (A. allosaccharophila) to 921 nucleotides (A. popoffii). The multiple alignment displayed 924 sites, 66 of which presented alignment gaps. The phylogenetic tree revealed the existence of two groups of species exhibiting different FlaA flagellins (FlaA1 and FlaA2). Maximum likelihood models of codon substitution were used to analyze flaA sequences. Likelihood ratio tests suggested a low variation in selective pressure among lineages, with an ω ratio of less than 1 indicating the presence of purifying selection in almost all cases. Only one site under potential diversifying selection was identified (isoleucine in position 179). However, 17 amino acid positions were inferred as sites that are likely to be under positive selection using the branch-site model. Ancestral reconstruction revealed that these 17 amino acids were among the amino acid changes detected in the ancestral sequence.
The models applied to our set of sequences allowed us to determine the possible evolutionary pathway followed by the flaA gene in Aeromonas, suggesting that this gene have probably been evolving independently in the two groups of Aeromonas species since the divergence of a distant common ancestor after one or several episodes of positive selection.
This article was reviewed by Alexey Kondrashov, John Logsdon and Olivier Tenaillon (nominated by Laurence D Hurst).
The genus Aeromonas belonging to the Gammaproteobacteria includes a group of 21 Gram- negative bacterial species that can be isolated worldwide from a variety of environments. Although it is clear that members of this genus are primarily aquatic organisms, they can colonize other habitats and cause infections in invertebrates and vertebrates . Recently, in their report of March 2006, the Office of Water of the Environmental Protection Agency of the USA (EPA) included some species of Aeromonas into a group of potential waterborne pathogens. Aeromonads are efficient colonizers of surfaces and are an important constituent of bacterial biofilms in both water distribution systems and food processing environments. Their polar flagellum contributes to biofilm formation and host colonization, as in the case of other bacterial genera such as Campylobacter and Pseudomonas . Additionally, in recent studies the role of the polar flagellum of Aeromonas in enterocyte adherence has been found to be similar to those of other seafood pathogens such as Vibrio .
The bacterial flagellum is the most important organelle of motility in bacteria and plays a key role in many bacterial lifestyles, including virulence . The flagellum also provides a paradigm of how hierarchical gene regulation, intricate protein-protein interactions and controlled protein secretion can result in the assembly of a complex multi-protein structure tightly orchestrated in time and space . As if to stress its importance, plants and animals produce receptors specifically dedicated to the recognition of flagella [6, 7]. Aside from motility, the flagellum also moonlights as an adhesion structure  and has been adapted by humans as a tool for peptide display .
Looking at the bacterial flagellum, instead of a simple model, there is an extensive variation in form and function. The most studied bacterial flagellar system is that of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, which exploits two different flagellins but never in the same filament, while in other cases, up to six different flagellins are incorporated into a single filament . Flagellar filaments vary in their physical properties: some are rigid, others flexible, some are straight, others curly, some undergo post-transcriptional modifications such as glycosilation or methylation, others do not.
A comparison of the flagellins amino acid sequences (fliC, flaA and flaB) from many bacterial species has revealed a distinctive domain structure of the protein. The N- and C-terminal parts of the molecule, which are responsible for the secretion and polymerization, are conserved among species, whereas the central region, which produces the surface exposed antigenic part of the flagellar filament, is highly variable both within and among species. The N-terminal region comprises two domains, ND0 and ND1, with a highly conserved region between them, the spoke region (12 residues). The C-terminal region includes two domains, CD0 and CD1, with the corresponding counterpart to the spoke region, CS, between them . The central variable region is less constrained, and includes sequences of variable length. Recent studies have shown that the N- and C-terminal conserved regions are recognized by the innate immune systems of mammals and plants . In Aeromonas, two flagellin genes have been reported, flaA and flaB, which are present even in species described as non motile .
Natural selection has clearly rendered flagellar systems non-functional when they are no longer needed. Vestigial non-functional remnants of flagellar genes or regulons have been discovered in several bacterial species [12, 13]. At least one degenerate flagellar system from Brucella melitensis still has a cryptic role in infection, even though it is no longer capable of mediating motility . More recently, flagellar-related genes have been detected in the genome of Myxococcus xanthus, a soil bacteria that uses gliding rather than flagellar motility . In addition, when examining homologies between flagellar and other bacterial proteins, it becomes clear that flagellar subunits share a common ancestry with components from other biological systems .
In this work we have determined the complete sequence of the flaA gene in 18 Aeromonas strains, including motile and non motile strains. Direct sequencing of the flaA gene has revealed the existence of two distinct FlaA flagellins (FlaA1 and FlaA2) that separate two groups of species (Group 1 and Group 2). The aim of the present study is to verify the role of the selective pressure acting on the flaA gene.
A comparison of synonymous (silent) and nonsynonymous (amino acid-changing) substitution rates in protein coding genes provides an important means for understanding molecular evolution. The nonsynonymous/synonymous rate ratio, ω (dN/dS), measures selective pressure at protein level. If nonsynonymous mutations are fixed at a lower rate than synonymous mutations, the ω ratio would be < 1 (purifying selection), while if both synonymous and nonsynonymous are fixed at the same rate, ω should be equal to 1 (neutrality). Finally, if nonsynonymous are higher than synonymous rates, ω should be >1 (positive selection).
To perform this study, we applied a maximum likelihood (ML) analysis based on models developed by Yang  to the 18 flaA gene sequence data. Researchers have begun to substitute the traditional null hypothesis testing approach for that of model selection, in which several competing hypotheses are simultaneously contrasted with the data. Models can be ranked and weighted, providing a quantitative measure of relative support for the competing hypothesis and in cases where models have similar levels of support from the data, model averaging can be used to make robust parameter estimates and predictions. This analysis is a valuable alternative especially when more than one hypothesis is plausible. Likelihood models developed by Yang  account for variable ω ratios among branches in the tree and can be used to test adaptative evolution along lineages. These models also allow the ω ratio to vary among amino acid sites and to identify critical amino acids under diversifying selection. In this work, we have applied the maximum likelihood models to our set of sequences in order to clarify the evolutionary pathway followed by the flaA gene in Aeromonas.
Analysis of flaAgene
Origin of the Aeromonas strains used and characteristics of their flaA sequences
flaA gene (bp)
G+C content (% mol)
GenBank accession n°.
A. hydrophila subsp. anaerogenes
A. hydrophila subsp. dhakensis
A. hydrophila subsp. hydrophila
A. hydrophila subsp. ranae
A. salmonicida subsp. salmonicida
A. salmonicida subsp. pectinolytica
A. veronii bv. Sobria
The average transition/transversion ratio was 1.0, two times the value expected with a random substitution distribution. The G + C content varied from 49.2% (A. jandaei) to 58.3% (A. bivalvium). The average nucleotide frequencies were 20.6%, 29.3%, 24.9% and 25.2% for T, C, A and G, respectively.
The mean number of transversions for pairwise comparisons between sequences pertaining to Group 1 and 2 was 128.27 ± 0.62 whereas the values for intragroups were: 60.06 ± 10.01 for Group 1 and 58.89 ± 9.81 for Group 2. In the case of transitions the intergroup value obtained was 108.53 ± 1.17, and in the case of the intragroup comparisons, the values obtained were 75.08 ± 3.13 and 92.89 ± 2.47 for Group 1 and 2, respectively.
Considering all these results, we decided to perform different genetic analyses in order to find the evolutionary models that could account for multiple substitutions and homoplasy as well as for the transition/transversion ratio and the different proportion of nucleotide base frequencies.
We compared 28 different models of nucleotide substitution: JC69 , K80 , F81 , F84 , HKY , N93  and GTR [23, 24]. In all cases models were modified by considering a proportion of invariant sites (option I) and/or assuming a gamma distribution of substitution rates among sites (option G). The General Time Reversible model (GTR) with a proportion of invariant sites of 0.432 and a gamma shape parameter α = 1.117 (GTR + I+ G) obtained the best Log likelihood scores. Hierarchical likelihood ratio tests and Akaike Information Criterion  both favoured the GTR + I + G model. The Akaike weight of this model, which can be interpreted as a probability, was 0.971 corroborating that the GTR + I + G is the most accurate model for the analysis of the observed data. This model implemented in the PHYML program was later used for inferring the phylogenetic tree of the 18 species and subspecies studied. However, identical or very similar topologies were obtained with other substitution models and clustering methods.
The mean intergroup number of pairwise nucleotide differences, 236.8 ± 1.4, was significantly higher than the mean intragroup pairwise differences: 135.1 ± 5.9 (Group 1) and 151 ± 4.1 (Group 2), (t test, P < 10-15). The differences between Group 1 and 2 were significant only at a level of 95% (t test, P = 0.03).
The amino acid alignment showed the existence of two different FlaA proteins among the Aeromonas species: FlaA1, which is present in Aeromonas species included in Group 1, and FlaA2, the flagellin exhibited by the species of Aeromonas belonging to Group 2. The comparative sequence analysis of these groups revealed the existence of amino acid residues fixed in different positions along the conserved regions of the protein, which varied between FlaA1 and FlaA2 flagellins. There were 14 of these residues in the N-terminal region (positions 18, 21, 74, 87, 105, 107, 114, 116, 121, 124, 126, 127, 133 and 142), 9 of which were in the ND1b domain (positions 105, 107, 114, 116, 121, 124, 126, 127 and 133), and 6 in the C-terminal region (positions 197, 198, 200, 205, 255 and 267). Only one of these fixed amino acid residues correspond to the central variable region (position 181). Furthermore, in the central region, all the sequences from species belonging to Group 1 exhibited a deletion of two amino acids (positions 164 and 165), which are not found in those of Group 2.
In order to clarify the role of selective pressures that operates in nucleotide diversity and sequence divergence of flaA in Aeromonas we performed a maximum likelihood analysis of flaA sequence data using the models developed by Nielsen and Yang  and Yang et al. , extending the model of codon substitution of Goldman and Yang  as implemented in the PAML4 package.
Pairwise sequence comparisons of dS and dN
As shown in Figure 4A, the 153 pairwise comparisons fell in two discrete and strikingly delimitated clusters with dN ranging from 0.002 to 0.082 (Cluster I) and 0.161 to 0.197 (Cluster II). Cluster I represents the 36 intragroup pairwise comparisons corresponding to the species of Group 1 (Cluster I.1) and the 36 pairwise comparisons between species of Group 2 (Cluster I.2). Cluster II includes the 81 pairwise intergroup comparisons.
In Figure 4B, ω was plotted against sequence divergence (t), defined as the number of nucleotide substitutions per codon and was approximately 3.07 × (0.247 dS + 0.753 dN), where 0.247 and 0.753 are the proportions of synonymous and nonsynonymous sites, respectively. In the case of pairs corresponding to Cluster II, there was a clear inverse relationship between ω and t, with a highly significant statistical correlation (r = -0.9032, P < 10-15). The correlation between ω and t for Cluster I.2 was also significant (r = -0.4507, P = 0.0058). However, in the case of Cluster I.1 the correlation between ω and t was not statistically significant (r = -0.1153, P = 0.5030).
Variability of the ω ratio among codon sites
Log-likelihood, AIC and parameter estimates under random-site models for flaA sequences
Estimates of parameters
Positively selected sites
M0: one ratio
0.062 ± 0.000
ω = 0.062
M1a: nearly neutral
0.114 ± 0.015
p0 = 0.92 (p1 = 0.08)
ω = 0.034, ω = 1
M2a: positive selection
0.114 ± 0.015
p0 = 0.918, p1 = 0.082,
(p2 = 0.000), ω0 = 0.034,
ω1 = 1; ω2 = 58.267
179 I (at P = 0.747)
M3: discrete (K = 3)
0.071 ± 0.008
p0 = 0.675, p1 = 0.254
(p2 = 0.071), ω0 = 0.003
ω1 = 0.122, ω2 = 0.546
0.071 ± 0.009
p = 0.152, q = 1.683
M8: beta & ω > 1
0.072 ± 0.008
p0 = 0.996, (p1 = 0.004)
p = 0.160, q = 1.976
ω = 1.92
179 I (at P = 0.967)
M8a: beta & ωs = 1
0.072 ± 0.008
p0 = 0.991, (p1 = 0.009)
p = 0.165, q = 2.190
ω = 1.0
Likelihood Ratio Test statistics (LRT) for random-site models
P – value
1.4 10-97 ***
We applied the simplest of site-based models, M0 , which assumes an uniform ω ratio for all codons, to the data. The log likelihood for our sequences was ℓ = -6830.350, with an estimate of ω = 0.062, which can be interpreted as an average over all sites in the protein and all lineages in the tree. The low ω value obtained suggests a strong action of purifying selection in the evolution of flaA in the Aeromonas species studied.
Model M1a (nearly neutral), which hypothesizes a variable selective pressure among sites but not positive selection and M2a, which considers positive selection, fit our data better than the M0 model, with an ℓ = -6689.544 in both cases (Table 2). The LRT between M1a and M2a models allow the nearly neutral model to be rejected (Table 3). However, in the case of the M2a model, the proportion of sites with ω > 1 (p2 = 0) was null. Hence, no site was positively selected at a level of 95% and only an isoleucine in position 179 was identified as being under positive selection at a level of 75% (Table 2). These results also suggest the absence of positive selection among sites in flaA sequences.
In contrast, model M3 that assumes an unconstrained discrete distribution with three site classes (p0, p1, p2) and ω ratios (ω0, ω1, ω2) fits the data much better than M0 (ℓ = -6601.883); the value of the statistic test was 2Δℓ = 456.93, compared with the χ2 distribution with df = 4, showing strong evidence against the null hypothesis (M0) in favour of the alternative (M3). However, the parameter estimates of the M3 model also suggest that all codons are under purifying selection with all sites with an ω < 0.6 (Table 2).
The most stringent test we carried out compared the M7 model, which assumes a beta distribution of ω over sites, with the M8, which adds an extra site class with a free ω ratio estimated from the data, allowing ω values greater than one (Table 2). Both models fitted the data better than M0 with values of ℓ = -6603.940 and -6600.818, respectively (Table 2). At a significance level of 95% we can reject the null hypothesis (M7 model) and accept the M8 model (Table 3), assuming the existence of ω values higher than 1, but at a level of 99% we should reject this hypothesis. In addition, the AIC value for the M8 model was only slightly lower (13209.635) than the value for the M7 model (13211.879).
Variability of the ω ratio among lineages
In order to identify those branches in the tree constructed from the flaA sequences with an ω ratio > 1 we applied the free-ratio models. The one ratio model (M0) assumes the same ω ratio for all lineages and when applied to our data involves a total of 44 parameters: branch lengths in the tree (33), nucleotide frequencies at the three codon positions (9), κ, and ω .
As shown in Table 2 the log-likelihood under this model was -6830.350, with ω = 0.062 as an average over all sites and lineages. We applied the free-ratio model, which assumes an independent ω ratio for each branch of the tree, to the same data set . Estimates of the ω ratios are detailed in Figure 3. Considering the 33 branches of the tree, this model includes 32 additional parameters. The log-likelihood was ℓ1 = -6768.362. We performed an LRT using the M0 model as the null hypothesis. Comparison of 2Δℓ = 2(ℓ1 - ℓ0) = 123.98 with the χ232 distribution suggests the rejection of the one-ratio model (P = 0.9 × 10-12). Although ω ratios varies among lineages (Fig. 3), the values of ω ratios corresponding to the different branches were significantly lower than one (t test, P = 2.2 × 10-16). The range was from 0.0001 to 0.3307 with a mean of 0.0845 and a standard error of 0.0156.
The ω ratios inferred under the model M8 were scattered along the codon sites, with the highest values clustering in the region between codon 105 and 205 (Fig. 5). We applied the fixed-site models to our data in order to determine if the different sites along the sequences were under different selective constraints. We partitioned codon sites into three sections, 1: N-terminal (104 codons), 2: the central region (101 codons) and 3: the C-terminal (80 codons). The correspondence of these sections with the three regions of the flagellin is depicted in Figure 5.
Log-likelihood values and parameter estimates under fixed-site models for flaA sequences
A (homogeneous model)
B (different rs)
rs2 = 4.473
rs3 = 1.614
C (different rs and πsc)
rs2 = 5.595
rs3 = 1.608
D (different rs, κ, and ω)
rs2 = 3.372
rs3 = 1.703
κ1 = 2.089
κ2 = 1.929
κ3 = 2.958
ω1 = 0.025
ω2 = 0.084
ω3 = 0.026
D2 (different rs and ω)d
rs2 = 3.439
rs3 = 1.650
ω1 = 0.025
ω2 = 0.084
ω3 = 0.025
E (different rs, κ and ω, and different πs)
rs2 = 3.944
rs3 = 1.688
κ1 = 1.929
κ2 = 1.929
κ3 = 3.005
ω1 = 0.023
ω2 = 0.083
ω3 = 0.025
Likelihood Ratio Test statistics for fixed-site models
5.8 10-81 ***
3.9 10-7 ***
different κ, ω
0.5 10-13 ***
1.4 10-7 ***
Parameter estimates for branch-site model A
Selected sites under positive selectionc
87G 105S 107K
110E 116V 120G
135T 141S 153N
157G 162Q 174K
Model A with ω = 1b
176T 185G 191Q
The LRT comparing the branch-site model with the null hypothesis model with ω = 1 gave a 2Δℓ = 14.20, and P = 0.0002, a significant value that indicated the existence of positive selection in this branch. We examined the Bayes Empirical Bayes (BEB) posterior probabilities to infer the sites that are likely to be under positive selection. The results of this test (Table 6) showed that 17 sites were identified as positively selected (P > 95%). We also applied an ML reconstruction of ancestral sequences using the codon model of Goldman and Yang  and Yang et al. . It is noteworthy that all the 17 sites identified as positively selected among the amino acid changes are in the ancestral sequence revealed by the analysis (Fig. 3).
The flagellin gene is a widely applicable and useful genetic marker for studying variation within species of closely related bacteria . Selander et al. have reported that the high level of variability and rapid evolution of flagellins provide a unique opportunity to test phylogenetic hypotheses . In this work we studied 18 sequences of the flaA gene which codifies for the flagellar filament protein FlaA, obtained from different species and subspecies of Aeromonas.
The flaA gene presented a high degree of variability. When comparing the average identity of the sequences analyzed (77.44% ± 0.50), it was significantly lower than that determined for the 16S rRNA in the same group of strains (98.89% ± 0.04, P < 10-86) with sequences obtained from the databases. This value was even lower than that of the housekeeping gene malate deshydrogenase (mdh) (90.89% ± 0.25, P > 10-64), calculated from sequences obtained in our laboratory with the same strains (data not shown).
The dN/dS mean value of our sequences (0.076 ± 0.003) was similar to that determined by Jordan et al.  for 3106 orthologs (including essential and nonessential genes) in E. coli (0.081). However, it was much lower than that reported by Mamirova et al.  (0.462) for 22 Gammaproteobacteria. The dN/dS mean value obtained for the flaA sequences strongly suggests a predominant action of purifying selection. Nevertheless, if we focused our attention exclusively on the dS values, both the mean (1.494 ± 0.047) and the range (0.074–3.529) were notably high. These data agree with the saturation plot (Fig. 1), in which both transitions and transversions show a clear saturation for divergence values higher than 1.0.
The plot of amino acid substitutions against transitions and transversions (Fig. 2) clearly demonstrated a strong saturation in the flaA sequences when pairwise comparisons between the two groups (Group 1 and 2), were considered. Pearson's product moment correlation (r) between the number of transitions and the number of amino acid substitutions was 0.004 (F test, P = 0.972), which reveals the null influence of this type of mutations on the diversification of the two proteins. It is known that due to the structure of the genetic code, transversions produce more nonsynonymous changes and a higher proportion of radical amino acid changes, which involve an alteration of a certain physicochemical property . Nevertheless, the correlation between the number of transitions and amino acid substitutions in pairwise comparisons between the flaA sequences corresponding to Group 1 and 2, although significant at a 95% level, was very low (r = 0.224; F test, P = 0.044), explaining only 5% of the variation. However, this correlation is significant when considering pairwise comparisons between the sequences. The product moment correlation values for transitions and transversions in Group 1 were r = 0.792 (F test, P < 10-8) and r = 0.800 (F test, P < 10-8), respectively, and in Group 2 were r = 0.602(F test, P = 0.0001) and r = 0.761 (F test, P < 10-7), respectively.
Most of the models applied to the flaA sequences determined that nearly all the sites are under purifying selection with only one site, the isoleucine in position 179, having an ω > 1 at a level of 95% (Tables 2, 4 and 6). This is not surprising since this amino acid is located in the central region of the flagellin, a surface exposed domain that is free to vary far more widely. Indeed, in other bacterial species the central region is considered to be under neutral or positive selection pressure . Nevertheless, the branch-site model suggests episodes of positive selection in the separation of the two flagellins in Aeromonas species. The branch-site models attempt to detect positive selection that affects only a few sites along a few lineages [34, 35]. In the case of branch-site model A, all the sites positively selected are included in those identified as ancestral (Fig. 3, Table 6). Seven of the 17 sites identified as positively selected correspond to fixed amino acids that are identical for all the species included in a group but different between groups. The remaining sites correspond to positions with fixed amino acids in one group but not in the other. In addition, twelve of the positively selected 17 sites are radical amino acid substitutions. In conclusion, all the positions identified as positively selected contributed to the diversification of the two flagellins detected in Aeromonas, FlaA1 and FlaA2.
These results can be explained considering the possible existence of two flaA genes (flaA1 and flaA2) among the Aeromonas species studied. These genes would have been diverging over a long period of time accumulating all the possible substitutions leading to amino acid changes allowed by the functional constraints of the flagellins. The results obtained with the codon models that account for selection on different codon sites or within specific lineages (Tables 2 and 4) suggested that both transitions and transversions would be submitted to a strong purifying selection.
In the analysis described in this paper, alignment gaps in the variable region of the flagellin were removed. It is known that in many bacterial species, the central region of the genes that codify the flagellin (flaA, flaB, fliC) is polymorphic and highly diverse with numerous gaps . In order to determine the effect of alignment gaps, we also analyzed our sequences with the 66 alignment gaps included and treated them as ambiguity data [42, 43]. The sequences then contained 307 codons (921 nucleotides). When comparing the sequences, with and without gaps using the one ratio estimate model, the values obtained were very similar, 0.078 and 0.062, respectively (Table 2). In addition, both values were clearly lower than one. When we determined the parameter estimates using the M8 model (beta & ω > 1) the values obtained (p0 = 0.982, p1 = 0.018, p = 0.160, q = 1.670) were similar to those shown in Table 2. The only site identified as being under positive selection was again the isoleucine, now in position 182 because of the gaps included in the analysis. We also carried out the analysis of the sequences using the branch-site model A (Table 4) to corroborate if the presence of alignment gaps influenced the detection and identification of sites under positive selection. The results confirm that the sites identified as being under positive selection were identical to those previously identified when we conducted the analysis excluding the gaps.
These results demonstrated that although alignment gaps in the sequence analyses have a certain impact on the estimates of model parameters; they do not seem to influence the identification of sites under positive selection. However, insertions and deletions can play an important role in the divergence of both flagellins (e.g. the indel of two amino acids that appears in all the species of Group 1, positions 164 and 165).
In conclusion, the maximum likelihood models applied to our set of sequences allowed us to determine the possible evolutionary pathway followed by the flaA gene in Aeromonas. The results indicated that this gene has probably been evolving independently in the two groups of Aeromonas since the divergence of a distant common ancestor after one or several episodes of positive selection in the branch that separates these groups. The saturation of nonsynonymous changes determined in the flaA sequences revealed that the flagellins that define those groups of species have accumulated all the amino acid changes allowed by the restriction structural constraints of the protein.
Bacterial strains and DNA isolation
A total of 18 Aeromonas strains were analyzed including type and reference strains of the genera (Table 1). All strains were grown aerobically on Tryptone soy agar (TSA) at 30°C. Isolates were stored in TSB containing 20% glycerol at -40°C. Genomic DNA was extracted with the REALPURE® Genomic DNA extraction kit (REAL RBMEG03, Durviz, Spain), and stored at 20°C until use.
Specific primers were designed from published polar flagella operons of some Aeromonas species [2, 11, 44] and the complete genome sequence of A. salmonicida subsp. salmonicida A449 (GenBank accession number CP000644). For PCR amplications, three sets of primers were designed to amplify the complete flaA gene and its flanking regions (yadS and flaB genes). The sense primers fla1 (5'-GCTGATGTAAACAATCTGCT-3') and fla5 (5'-GCTTAGGAGAATGGTTATG-3') are located at 437 nt and 16 nt, respectively, upstream of the translational start site of the flaA gene. The antisense primers fla2 (5'-GCGTTCAGTGATGAAGTATT-3') and fla2A (5'-CACCCCNTTGTTCCATCT-3') are located at 1541 nt and 977 nt, respectively, downstream of the initiator codon. A set of internal primers was used for sequencing PCR products: fla1A-2 (sense, 5'-ATCAACAGCGCNAANGA-3'), fla12 (sense, 5'-TCCAACCGTCTGACCTC-3'), fla10 (sense, 5'-GCCATGGATGAAGTGAC-3'), fla11 (sense, 5'-CANGTNGGNGCNGANGC-3') and fla7 (antisense, 5'- CGGTTNTGNACCGCACC-3'), which were located at base positions 112, 151, 241, 439 and 722, respectively, downstream of the translational start. Primer3 software was used to design PCR and sequencing primers http://primer3.sourceforge.net. The oligonucleotides were synthesized by Isogen Life Science (Maarssen, The Netherlands).
PCR amplification and DNA sequencing
PCR reactions were carried out in a 50 μl volume, containing 0.5–10 μl of genomic DNA as template, 1× PCR buffer I (10× PCR buffer I: 500 mM KCl, 15 mM MgCl2, 100 mM Tris-HCl [pH 8.3]), 2 mM MgCl2, 0.2 mM each dNTP, 10 pmol each primer and 1 U of AmpliTaq Gold DNA polymerase (Applied Biosystems). Amplifications were performed in an Applied Biosystems 2720 thermal cycler using the following program: initial denaturation at 94°C for 5 min, followed by 35 cycles of denaturation at 94°C for 45 s, annealing at 45–50°C for 1 min and elongation at 72°C for 1.30 min, and a final extension at 72°C for 10 min. PCR products were resolved by electrophoresis, and amplicons were purified with a MSB® Spin PCRapace kit (Invitek) or from agarose gel with a QIAquick® Gel Extraction kit (Qiagen). Purified PCR products were directly sequenced on both strands using either the PCR primers or internal primers. Sequencing reactions were performed with an ABI PRISM® BigDye® Terminator v3·1 Cycle Sequencing kit (Applied Biosystems) and analyzed on an ABI PRISM 3700 DNA sequencer (Applied Biosystems) by the Genomics Unit of the Scientific and Technical Services of the University of Barcelona (SCT-UB).
The nucleotide sequences obtained were examined for open reading frames (ORFs) with the ORF finder program and were also compared to the GenBank database using a BLASTN analysis, both available at the NCBI http://0-www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov.brum.beds.ac.uk/. Sequence data were translated, aligned using ClustalX  according to the system default parameters, and back translated to obtain the nucleotide alignments. The multiple alignment contained 66 sites with alignment gaps. These sites and the termination codons were removed, giving sequences of 855 bp length for all strains (285 codons). All subsequent analyses were performed on this set of aligned DNA sequences.
The PHYML package  was used for tree reconstructions in combination with the most likely model of nucleotide substitution identified by two hierarchical tests, the likelihood ratio test (LRT) and Akaike's information criterion (AIC) [25, 47]. Model selection and tree statistics were done using the APE package  and R language . The DnaSP software  was used to obtain the DNA polymorphism data. The identity of the sequences, the number of transitions and transversions and the amino acid substitutions were calculated by using the MEGA 4 program .
The synonymous substitutions rate (synonymous substitutions per synonymous site dS), nonsynonymous substitutions rate (nonsynonymous substitutions per nonsynonymous site, dN) and dN/dS ratio (ω) were calculated using the Nei-Gojobori (NG) method  and the codon-based model of Goldman and Yang  as implemented in the codeml program of the PAML 4 package . The latter is a maximum likelihood (ML) method based on an explicit model of codon substitution, which accounts for the transition/transversion rate (κ), ω, and the base frequencies at the three codon positions.
Standard codon models were fitted to the data set with the PAML software, and likelihood ratio tests (LRT) were used to determine the relative fit of the hierarchically nested models. Likelihood ratio test statistic 2Δℓ = 2(ℓ1 - ℓ0), where ℓ1 represents the log-likelihood of the model corresponding to the alternative hypothesis and ℓ0 is the log-likelihood corresponding to the model used as null hypothesis, were compared with a chi-squared distribution in which the difference between the number of parameters of both models gives the degrees of freedom (χ2df) .
Models tested included those that account for selection in different codon sites, within specific lineages, or a combination of selection in different sites within specific lineages. Parameters and other details involved in these models are explicit in the Results section. For all models the equilibrium codon frequencies were estimated from the products of the average observed nucleotide frequencies in the three codon positions (option F3 × 4 in the PAML package). To verify convergence all PAML analyses were run at least three times from distinct starting values of parameters and seed used.
Other statistical analyses and graphics were done in the R language and Microsoft Excel. Unless otherwise indicated, uncertainty is expressed as the standard error.
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers
The nucleotide sequences determined in this study have been deposited in the GenBank database under accession numbers EU410305 to EU410318 and EU410320 to EU410323.
Dr Alexey Kondrashov, University of Michigan, Life Sciences Institute, Michigan, USA This reviewer provided no comments for publication.
Dr John Logsdon, Department of Biology, University of Iowa, Iowa City, USA
This paper reports the isolation and analysis of flagellin gene sequences from a diverse collection of 18 Aeromonas species and subspecies. Genes were isolated by PCR and the resulting products were sequenced directly. By this method, each species yielded a single flagellin gene sequence. The authors use detailed molecular evolutionary analyses to assess the pattern and strength of selection on these genes.
The phylogenetic analysis showed two distinct groupings of these genes that the authors term FlaA1 and FlaA2. Even though it is well-known that Aeromonas species generally contain two tandemly-linked flagellin genes (FlaA and FlaB), the authors seem to have missed the most logical interpretation that their so-called FlaA1 and FlaA2 are actually FlaA and FlaB (respectively, or vice versa). Unfortunately, the authors seemed to have missed this obvious conclusion, made even stronger by the fact that the underlying Aeromonas species phylogeny (as recently published by Saavedra et al., 2006, IJSEM 56: 2481) is not at all congruent with the authors' flagellin gene phylogeny shown in their Figure 3.
Regarding the main objection you pointed out in your revision, the misinterpretation of the two flagellin genes, we are aware that the flagellin operon of Aeromonas is composed of the flaA and flaB genes as cited in the manuscript (background: paragraph 4).
Concerning the phylogeny of Aeromonas published by Saavedra et al., the incongruences are not surprising because the work of these authors is based on the partial sequences of two housekeeping genes (gyrB and rpoD) that are supposed to be selectively neutral, while we have analyzed sequences from a gene that codifies an external protein that is subjected to high selective pressure. Despite the above, our intention was not to construct a phylogeny of Aeromonas based on the sequences of flaA gene.
This appears to be a classic case of not discerning between paralogs and orthologs in a phylogenetic analysis caused by the arbitrary selection of one paralog or the other from a given genome. It is clear that the two groups of flagellar genes (which I interpret to be FlaA and FlaB) are paralogs that diverged early in Aeromonas evolution. The fact that each Aeromonas species gave only one sequence (either FlaA1 or FlaA2, according to the authors' naming) could be simply due to the direct sequencing of amplicons. Presumably, any mixed amplicons would yield poor sequence, since paralogs within species are ~80 identical; but if clones from those presumed-mixed amplicons were prepared and sequenced, then two distinct versions would be predicted.
The serious issue in not distinguishing between paralogous flagellin genes (i.e., FlaA and FlaB) undermines the entire analysis of this paper and its interpretation. In my view this fundamental flaw renders the paper unacceptable for publication in Biology Direct at this time. However, the details of the selection analyses of the sequences per se appear to be sound, even if the evolutionary context necessary for appropriate interpretation is indeed incorrect. Thus, with a careful re-framing of the analysis in a manner that determines and then clarifies the appropriate evolutionary history of these genes in Aeromonas, the paper would likely be appropriate for publication in Biology Direct.
The presence of two flagellin genes located genetically in tandem in Aeromonas has been taken into account when we designed the primers used for the PCR amplification and direct sequencing of the full length sequences of the flaA gene (methods section). The PCR primers used were designed from the two genes flanking flaA in Aeromonas, yadS (forward) and flaB (reverse). With these primers we obtained a sequence that includes the full length flaA gene plus a region upstream that contains part of yadS and another downstream that includes part of the flaB gene. As a consequence it is not possible to mistake the amplified region and we are sure in all cases we amplified flaA.
In addition, we conducted a BLASTN analysis with the sequences obtained from our strains and in all cases without exceptions, the sequences showed a high homology with other Aeromonas flaA sequences available in the GenBank as we explained in the manuscript (results: paragraph 1).
Finally, in order to confirm that our sequences correspond to the flaA gene we constructed a new maximum likelihood tree (additional file 1), in which we have incorporated four flaB Aeromonas sequences from the GenBank database. As you can see, flaB sequences clustered in a second major branch in both groups (Group 1 and Group 2), showing that probably they could also be two alleles of flaB genes in Aeromonas as we observed in the case of flaA, or even two different flagellin operons.
Dr Olivier Tenaillon, INSERM U722, Faculté de Médecine Xavier Bichat, Paris, France (nominated by Dr Laurence D Hurst)
The present article provides an analysis of the flagellin gene flaA in the opportunistic pathogen species complex of Aeromonas. As flagella is exposed it has been shown to be under diversifying selection in several species, it appear to be a good candidate to study traces of positive selection with PAML. Yet in the present study most signal are compatible with stabilizing selection rather than diversifying selection.
I think to be more relevant, the analysis should be coupled with a phylogenetic analysis of a gene subject to less selective pressure such as mdh that the author mention they have sequenced too. This will for instance give more power to the analysis of the diversification of flaA in two groups. Are the species showing the same pattern or is it specific to flaA gene? If the diversification is specific this will comfort the idea that positive selection has been at work.
As the referee suggest, we have included an additional file (additional file 2), which shows the phylogenies inferred from mdh and flaA gene sequences from different Aeromonas species and subspecies. The trees depict distinct phylogenies, mdh being much more in accordance with other housekeeping gene phylogenies for Aeromonas, and confirming that the two groups of strains obtained in the flaA tree were a consequence of the divergence of the two alleles of flaA, suggesting an early episode of positive selection in their origin.
However one possible explanation is also that a duplication occurred and that a single copy get conserved or sequenced in each subgroup. Could this be simply rejected?
Following the Occham's razor principle, the simplest and most probable hypothesis is that in prokaryotes, after a duplication, both copies of the gene are conserved, usually in tandem or, less frequently, in a distant region of the chromosome. Concerning the sequencing of a single copy in each subgroup, this fact should be rejected, considering that, as we mentioned above in the answer to Dr Logsdon, the PCR primers used were designed from the two genes flanking flaA in Aeromonas, yadS (forward) and flaB (reverse). With these primers we obtained a sequence that includes the full length flaA gene plus a region upstream that contains part of yadS and another downstream that includes part of the flaB gene. As a consequence it is not possible to mistake the amplified region and we are sure in all cases we amplified flaA.
The strong saturation observed could limit the usage of the PAML like software, it could be appropriate to split the dataset in the two groups to see if any more signal would emerge. Also along those lines, the estimation of omega along the sequence as shown in the figure 5 reveals a very contrasted pattern between 0–120, 120–210, and 210 till the end of the protein. Analyzing those regions separately could also give increased power. Indeed branch site models should in theory do the job of separating branches and sites but as they compare to other sites and branches, having large heterogeneity might affect the power to detect selection.
Firstly, we are not sure about the possibility of splitting the dataset in two groups because of the low number of sequences in each of them (nine). Anyway, we have conducted the PAML analysis considering these two groups as you suggest, and the results obtained are not conclusive. Estimation of omega along different parts of the sequence protein shows that although the central region is less constrained (with omega values 0.0787) than the other two regions N- and C-terminal (with omega values 0.032 and 0.021, respectively), all these values are clearly lower than one, and do not modify the results.
I do not understand the information brought by the assertion «site under positive selection were found in the ancestral sequence», also in the conclusion the idea that all possible amino acid have been visited appear incompatible with dN/dS less than one and strong purifying selection. If no strong positive selection is observed in the recent diversification of the flaA gene could the biological implication be discussed as Aeromonas are mainly opportunistic pathogens.
We mean that the 17 sites identified as positively selected (P > 95%), when we applied the branch-site model A to our sequences (Table 6), were all of them are in the reconstructed ancestral sequence from which Group 1 and 2 diverged. Moreover, as that possibly happened a long time ago and since then both groups of sequences have evolved under purifying selection, the rate ratio of dN/dS is less than one.
The authors thank Drs Elena Bosch and Francesc Calafell for their helpful comments and Alicia Jiménez, Núria Magrinyà and Aintzane Urbizu for their valuable contribution to this study. We also thank the Unitat de Genòmica from the Serveis Científicotècnics, (SCT) at the Universitat de Barcelona for its technical support. This work was supported by projects CGL2004-03385/BOS and CGL2008-03281/BOS from the Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia, Spain.
- Martin-Carnahan A, Joseph SW: Genus I. Aeromonas Stanier 1943, 213AL. Bergey's Manual of Systematic Bacteriology. part B. Edited by: Brenner DJ, Krieg NR, Staley JT, Garrity GM. 2005, New York: Springer, 2: 557-578.Google Scholar
- Rabaan AA, Gryllos I, Tomás JM, Shaw JG: Motility and the polar flagellum are required for Aeromonas caviae adherence to Hep-2 cells. Infect Immun. 2001, 69: 4257-4267. 10.1128/IAI.69.7.4257-4267.2001.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kirov SDM, Castrisios M, Shaw JG: Aeromonas flagella (polar and lateral) are enterocyte adhesins that contribute to biofilm formation on surfaces. Infect Immun. 2004, 72: 1939-1945. 10.1128/IAI.72.4.1939-1945.2004.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Josenhaus C, Suerbaun S: The role of motility as a virulence factor in bacteria. Int J Med Microbiol. 2002, 291: 605-614. 10.1078/1438-4221-00173.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pallen MJ, Penn CW, Chandhuri RR: Bacterial flagellar diversity in the post-genomic era. Trends Microbiol. 2005, 13: 143-149. 10.1016/j.tim.2005.02.008.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ramos JHC, Rumbo M, Sirard JC: Bacterial flagellins: mediators of pathogenicity and host immune responses in mucosa. Trends Microbiol. 2004, 12: 509-517. 10.1016/j.tim.2004.09.002.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Andersen-Nissen E, Smith KD, Strobe KL, Rassoulian Barrett SL, Cookson BT, Logan SM, Aderem A: Evasion of Toll-like receptor 5 by flagellated bacteria. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2005, 102: 9247-9252. 10.1073/pnas.0502040102.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Westerlund-Wikstrom B: Peptide display on bacterial flagella: principles and applications. Int J Med Microbiol. 2000, 290: 223-230.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ely B, Ely TW, Crymes WB, Minnich SA: A family of six flagellin genes contributes to the Caulobacter crescentus flagellar filament. J Bacteriol. 2000, 182: 5001-5004. 10.1128/JB.182.17.5001-5004.2000.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beatson SA, Minamino T, Pallen MJ: Variation in bacterial flagellins: from sequence to structure. Trends Microbiol. 2006, 14: 151-155. 10.1016/j.tim.2006.02.008.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Umelo E, Trust TJ: Identification and molecular characterization of two tandemly located flagellin genes from Aeromonas salmonicida A449. J Bacteriol. 1997, 179: 5292-5299.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Monday SR, Minnich SA, Feng PCA: 12-base-pair deletion in the flagellar master control gene fliC causes nonmotility of the pathogenic German sorbitol fermenting Escherichia coli O157:H strains. J Bacteriol. 2004, 186: 2319-2327. 10.1128/JB.186.8.2319-2327.2004.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ren CP, Beatson SA, Parkhill J, Pallen MJ: The flag 2 locus, an ancestral gene cluster, is potentially associated with a novel flagellar system from Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol. 2005, 187: 1430-1440. 10.1128/JB.187.4.1430-1440.2005.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fretin D, Fauconnier A, Köhler S, Halling S, Léonard S, Nijskens C, Ferooz J, Lestrate P, Delrue RM, Danese I, Vandenhaute J, Tibor A, DeBolle X, Letesson JJ: The sheathed flagellum of Brucella melitensis is involved in persistence in a murine model of infection. Cell Microbiol. 2005, 7: 687-698. 10.1111/j.1462-5822.2005.00502.x.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pallen MJ, Matzke NJ: From the origin of species to the origin of bacterial flagella. Nature reviews. 2006, 4: 784-790. 10.1038/nrmicro1493.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z: PAML 4: a program package for phylogenetic analysis by maximum likelihood. Mol Biol Evol. 2007, 24: 1586-1591. 10.1093/molbev/msm088. [http://abacus.gene.ucl.ac.uk/software/paml.html]PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jukes TH, Cantor CR: Evolution of protein molecules. Mammalian Protein Metabolism. Edited by: Munro HN. 1969, New York: Academic Press, III: 21-132.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kimura M: A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitution through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences. J Mol Evol. 1980, 16: 111-120. 10.1007/BF01731581.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Felsenstein J: Evolutionary trees from DNA sequences: a maximum likelihood approach. J Mol Evol. 1981, 17: 368-376. 10.1007/BF01734359.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Felsenstein J: PHYLIP – phylogeny inference package (version 3.2). Cladistics. 1989, 5: 164-166.Google Scholar
- Hasegawa M, Kishino H, Yano T: Dating the human-ape splitting by a molecular clock of mitochondrial DNA. J Mol Evol. 1985, 22: 160-174. 10.1007/BF02101694.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tamura K, Nei M: Estimation of the number of nucleotide substitutions when there are strong transition-transversion and G+C content biases. Mol Biol Evol. 1993, 9: 678-687.Google Scholar
- Yang Z: Estimating the pattern of nucleotide substitution. J Mol Evol. 1994, 39: 105-111.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zharkikh A: Estimation of evolutionary distances between nucleotide sequences. J Mol Evol. 1994, 39: 315-329. 10.1007/BF00160155.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Akaike H: Information measures and model selection. Int Stat Inst. 1983, 22: 277-291.Google Scholar
- Nielsen R, Yang Z: Likelihood models for detecting positively amino acid sites and applications to the HIV-1 envelope gene. Genetics. 1998, 148: 929-936.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Nielsen R, Goldman N, Pedersen AM: Codon-substitution models for heterogeneous selection pressure at amino acid sites. Genetics. 2000, 155: 431-449.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Goldman N, Yang Z: A codon-based model of nucleotide substitution for protein-coding DNA sequences. Mol Biol Evol. 1994, 11: 725-736.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nei M, Gojobori T: Simple methods for estimating the numbers of synonymous and nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions. Mol Biol Evol. 1986, 3: 418-426.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Swanson WJ: Codon-substitution models to detect adaptive evolution that account for heterogeneous selective pressures among site classes. Mol Biol Evol. 2002, 19: 49-57.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Swanson WJ, Vacquier VD: Maximum-Likelihood analysis of molecular adaptation in Abalone sperm lysin reveals selective pressures among lineages and sites. Mol Biol Evol. 2000, 17: 1446-1455.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Bielawski JP: Statistical models for detecting molecular adaptation. Trends Ecol Evol. 2000, 15: 496-502. 10.1016/S0169-5347(00)01994-7.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Nielsen R: Codon-substitution models for detecting molecular adaptation at individual sites along specific lineages. Mol Biol Evol. 2002, 19: 908-917.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Wong WSW, Nielsen R: Bayes empirical Bayes inference of amino acid sites under positive selection. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 1197-1118.Google Scholar
- Zhang J, Nielsen R, Yang Z: Evaluation of an improved branch-site likelihood method for detecting positive selection at the molecular level. Mol Biol Evol. 2005, 22: 2472-2479. 10.1093/molbev/msi237.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z, Kumar S, Nei M: A new method of inference of nucleotide and amino acid ancestral sequences. Genetics. 1995, 141: 1641-1650.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Winstanley C, Morgan JAW: The bacterial flagellin gene as a biomarker for detection, population genetics and epidemiological analysis. Microbiol. 1997, 143: 3071-3084. 10.1099/00221287-143-10-3071.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Reid SD, Selander RK, Whittam TS: Sequence diversity of flagellin (fliC) alleles in pathogenic Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol. 1999, 181: 153-160.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Jordan K, Rogozin IB, Wolf YI, Koonin EV: Microevolutionary genomics of bacteria. Theor Pop Biol. 2002, 61: 435-447. 10.1006/tpbi.2002.1588.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mamirova L, Popadin K, Gelfand MS: Purifying selection in mitochondria, free-living and obligate intracellular proteobacteria. BMC Evol Biol. 2007, 7: 17-29. 10.1186/1471-2148-7-17.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Zhang J: Rates of conservative and radical nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions in mammalian nuclear genes. J Mol Evol. 2000, 50: 56-68.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z: Maximum likelihood estimation on large phylogenies and analysis of adaptive evolution in human influenza virus A. J Mol Evol. 2000, 51: 423-432.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Yang Z: Maximum likelihood analysis of adaptive evolution in HIV-1 gp120 env gene. Pac Symp Biocomput. 2001, 226-237.Google Scholar
- Canals R, Ramirez S, Vilches S, Horsburgh G, Shaw JG, Tomás JM, Merino S: Polar flagellum biogenesis in Aeromonas hydrophila. J Bacteriol. 2006, 188: 542-555. 10.1128/JB.188.2.542-555.2006.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Thompson JD, Gibson TJ, Plewniak F, Jeanmougin F, Higgins DG: The ClustalX windows interface: flexible strategies for multiple sequence alignment aided by quality analysis tools. Nucleic Acids Res. 1997, 25: 4876-4882. 10.1093/nar/25.24.4876.PubMedPubMed CentralView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Guindon S, Gascuel O: A simple, fast, and accurate algorithm to estimate large phylogenies by maximum likelihood. Syst Biol. 2003, 52: 696-704. 10.1080/10635150390235520.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Johnson JB, Omland KS: Model selection in ecology and evolution. Trends Ecol Evol. 2004, 19: 101-108. 10.1016/j.tree.2003.10.013.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Paradis E, Claude J, Strimmer K: APE: analyses of phylogenetics and evolution in R languages. Bioinformatics. 2004, 20: 289-290. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg412.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- R Development Core Team: R: A language and environment for statistical computing. 2007, R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, [http://www.r-project.org]Google Scholar
- Rozas J, Sánchez del Barrio JC, Messeguer X, Rozas R: DnaSP, DNA polymorphism analyses by the coalescent and other methods. Bioinformatics. 2003, 19: 2496-2497. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btg359.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tamura K, Dudley J, Nei M, Kumar S: MEGA 4: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis (MEGA) software version 4.0. Mol Biol Evol. 2007, 24: 1596-1599. 10.1093/molbev/msm092.PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.